where the discretion of the Department in that regard has been exercised in a capricious and arbitrary manner. Sinnes v. Daggett, 80 Wash. 673, 142 Pac. 5; Chalmers v. Industrial Insurance Commission, 94 Wash. 490, 162 Pac. 576; Parker v. Industrial Insurance Department, 102 Wash. 54, 172 Pac. 830; Foster v. Industrial Insurance Commission, 107 Wash, 400, 181 Pac. 912; Whipple v. Industrial Insurance Commission (Wash.) 199 Pac. 455; Sweitzer v. Industrial Insurance Commission (Wash.) 199 Pac. 724; Krause v. Industrial Insurance Commission (Wash.) 206 Pac. 358; Taylor v. Industrial Insurance Commission (Wash.) 206 Pac. 973. [2] The record in this case does not justify a finding that the appellant acted in such a manner in refusing to reopen the respondent's claim. The most that the record justifies is a finding that there is an honest difference of opinion between the doctors, and in such condition of the record, and in view of section 6604-21, Rem. Code, we are powerless to substitute what might be our judgment in the case for that of the appellant. Marney v. Industrial Insurance Department, 98 Wash. 483, 167 Pac. 1085. Judgment reversed. TABLE OF CASES REPORTED A cumulative list of cases in the current issue and all previous issues Anderson v. Commonwealth Oil & Refining Co. et al. (Kan. S. C.)........... 213 Anderson v. Miller Scrap Iron Co. et al. (Wis. S. C.) Appignani et al. v. Staten Island Rapid Transit Co. (N. Y. S. C.). 608 Berskis v. Lehigh Valley Coal Co. (Pa. S. C.) Baltimore Dry Docks & Ship Building Co. et al. v. Webster. (Md. Blue Diamond Plaster Co. v. Industrial Accident Commission of Cali- 102 fornia et al. (Cal. S. C.) 6 Bongialatte v. H. Wales Lines Co. et al. (Conn. S. C. E.) 547 Bouchon v. Southern Surety Co. et al. (La. S. C.). Burgi v. Jacob Hoffman Brewing Co. et al. (N. Y. S. C.) 71 623 537 Carterville & Big Muddy Coal Co. v. Industrial Commission et al. 15 Carterville & Big Muddy Coal Co. v. Industrial Commission et al. 376 Citizens' Coal Mining Co. v. Industrial Commission et al. (Ill. S. City of Grand Rapids v. Crocker et al. (Mich. S. C.) Cook v. Millers' Indemnity Underwriters (Tex. Com'n of Ap.) (1) Crawn v. Fowler Packing Co. (Kan. S. C.) 554 Crockett v. F. T. Coppino & Sons et al. (N. Y. S. C.) 612 Cudahy Packing Co. of Nebraska v. Industrial Commission of Utah et al. (Utah S. C.) ... 335 Dahlquist v. Nevada Industrial Commission. (Nev. S. C.) 55 (Nev. S. C.) 601 Dahn v. Davis, Agent, etc. (U. S. S. C.) 3 Dakota Central Telephone Co. v. Mitchell Power Co. (S. D. S. C.) 510 (La. S. C.) 429 Dewey v. Lutcher-Moore Lumber Co. (La. S. C.) Eikenbarry v. Northport Smelting & Refining Co. Ex parte Sloss-Sheffield Steel & Iron Co. (Ala. S. C.) Farrin v. State Industrial Acc. Commission. (Or. S. C.) Fidelity & Casualty Co. of New York v. St. Paul Gas Light Co. (Wash. S. C.) .. 643 84 Gates v. Texas Employers' Ins. Ass'n. (Tex. C. C. A.) Georgia Casualty Co. v. McClure. (Tex. C. C. A.) Grand Rapids Trust Co. v. Peterson Beverage Co. (Mich. S. C.) Greek v. Sloss-Sheffield Steel & Iron Co. (Ala. S. C.) Gregory et al. v. Standard Oil Co. of Louisiana (La. S. C.). Gross v. Michigan Iron & Chemical Co. et al. (Mich. S. C.) Guderian v. Sterling Sugar & Ry. Co., I'd. (La. S. C.).... Hale v. Gilliland Oil Co. (La. S. C.)....... Hall v. Industrial Accident Commission et al. Hamberg v. Flower City Specialty Co. et al. Hamilton et al. v. Texas Co. (La. S. C.) Hammett v. Gilliland Oil Co. (La. S. C.) Harbis v. Cudahy Packing Co. (Kansas City [Mo] C. A.) Heaps v. Industrial Commission et al. (Ill. S. C.) Hogan et al. v. State Industrial Commission et al. (Okla. S. C.) Holmberg v. Cleveland-Cliffs Iron Co. (Mich. S. C.) Johannsen v. Union Iron Works. (N. J. C. E. A.) 606 Johnson v. Vernon Parish Lumber Co. (La. S. C.) 441 Jones, W. A., Foundry & Machine Co. v. Industrial Commission et al. Kirk et al., Com'rs of State Industrial Accident Commission, v. Lengle et al. v. North Lebanon Tp. (Pa. S. C.) 506 Leon v. Crowell & Spencer Lumber Co. (La. S. C.) 443 Letourneau v. Davidson. (Mich. S. C.) 456 Los Angeles Shipbuilding & Drydock Co. v. Industrial Acc. Commis- 370 Lough v. State Industrial Accident Commission. (Ore. S. C.) Lumbermen's Indemnity Exchange et al. v. Vivier. (Tex. C. C. A.) 127 Lumbermen's Mut. Casualty Co. v. Industrial Commission et al. (III. 106 295 460 329 Maguire v. James Lees & Sons Co. (Pa. S. C.) Millers' Indemnity Underwriters v. Huffaker et al. (Tex. C. C. A.) 532 489 (3) Moore et al. v. Lumbermen's reciprocal ass'n. (Tex. C. C. A.) Morgan v. Philadelphia & Reading Coal & Iron Co. (Pa. S. C.) Newhall Land & Farming Co. et al. v. Industrial Acc. Commission Ohio Drilling Co. et al. v. State Industrial Commission et al. (Okla. Okmulgee Democrat Pub. Co. v. State Industrial Commission of 493 75 Price et al. v. Yellow Pine Paper Mill Co. (Tex. C. C. A.) Quave v. Lott-Batson Lumber Co., Limited. (La. S. C.) Richardson v. Farmers' Co-operative Union. (S. D. S. C.) Riley v. Ruud. (Mass. S. J. C.) St. Louis Pressed Steel Co. v. Schorr. (Ill. S. C.) 405 St. Louis Smelting & Refining Co. et al. v. State Industrial Commis- 626 Standard Oil Co. of Louisiana v. Parham (U. S. C. C. A.).. 173 623 State Treasurer v. West Side Trucking Co. et al. (N. Y. C. A.) ... 271 13 251 Taylor v. Industrial Ins. Commission of Washington (Wash. S. C.).. 354 202 Tintic Milling Co. et al. v. Industrial Commission of Utah et al. 145 1 |