DETERMINED IN

THE SUPREME COURT

OF THE

STATE OF CALIFORNIA,

AT THE

OCTOBER TERM, 1872,

AND

JANUARY AND APRIL TERMS, 1873.

CHARLES A. TUTTLE,

REPORTER.

Volume 45.

SECOND EDITION.

SAN FRANCISCO:

SUMNER WHITNEY & CO.,

613 CLAY STREET.

A. L. BANCROFT & CO.,

721 MARKET STREET.

1882.