LIST OF CASES

(Note.-S. D. R. is an abbreviation for State Department Reports; the texts of cases are indicated by stars preceding their page numbers.)

PAGE

Nov. 29, 1916;- - N. Y.

327

248

.127, *131

.197, 265

*141, 142

Allen v. State of New York, S. D. R., vol. 6, p. 376, Dec. 15, 1915; 173 App. Div. 455, June 30, 1916.....

App.

Avanzato v. Erie R. R. Co., S. D. R., vol. 4, p. 397, June 4, 1915;
Div.; -, S. D. R., vol. 8, p. 414, Mar. 21, 1916..
Aylesworth v. Phoenix Cheese Co., S. D. R., vol. 3, p. 383, Mar. 9, 1915; 170
App. Div. 34, Nov. 10, 1915..

Bargey v. Massaro Macaroni Co., S. D. R., vol. 4, p. 373, Apr. 30, 1915; 170
App. Div. 103, Nov. 10, 1915; 218 N. Y. 410, June 16, 1916...134, *137, *139, 142
Bechmann v. Oelerich, 174 App. Div. 353, Sept. 13, 1916.

Bell v. Terry & Tench, -App. Div.

Bennett v. Russell & Sons Co., S. D. R., vol. 6, p. 403, Jan. 5, 1916..

Benton v. Frazier, S. D. R., vol. 5, p. 392, Aug. 11, 1915; 172 App. Div. 913, Jan. 5, 1916; 219 N. Y. 210, Oct. 31, 1916.

*260

308

197

.153, *193, 264

Berg v. Great Lakes Dredge & Dock Co., 173 App. Div. 82, May 3, 1916....*80, 116
Berger v. Shadboldt Mfg. Co., S. D. R., vol. 8, p. 460, Apr. 27, 1916.. ..307, 308
Berliner v. Ritchie & Cornell, S. D. R., vol. 4, p. 446, July 12, 1915; 172 App.
Div. 913, Jan. 5, 1916...

.153, *193, 264

Birn v. Bradley Contracting Co., S. D. R., vol. 6, p. 319, Nov. 3, 1915..
Bloom v. Jaffe, 94 Misc. 222, Mar. 13, 1916...

388 *271

..358, 361

.254, 255, 264, *390

253

Bloom v. Tilin & Bleek, S. D. R., vol. 5, p. 441, Nov. 13, 1915.. Bloomfield v. November, S. D. R., vol. 5, p. 385, Aug. 2, 1915; 172 App. Div. 917, Jan., 1916; 219 N. Y. 374, Dec. 12, 1916.... Boesenberg v. Butterick Publishing Co., S. D. R., vol. 4, p. 367, April 29, 1915.. 98 Bridgeman v. McLoughlin, S. D. R., vol. 7, p. 425, Feb. 9, 1916... Brolesk v. Nichols Copper Co., 171 App. Div. 959, Nov., 1915.. Brown v. Richmond Light & R. R. Co., S. D. R., vol. 7, p. 371, Jan. 13, 1916; vol. 7, p. 420, Feb. 3, 1916; 173 App Div. 432, June 30, 1916. Buell v. N. Y. Central & H. R. R. R. Co., S. D. R., vol. 6, pp. 361, 377, Dec. 14, 16, 1915..

367

*151, 255

*335

Burke v. I. E. Co., Files of Commission, Claim No. 30288, Feb. 8, 1915..
Burns v. Southern Pacific Co., 167 App. Div. 945, Mar., 1915; 215 N. Y. 120,
July 13, 1916......

333

*28

Burton v. Whelen & Sons, S. D. R., vol. 5, p. 395, Aug. 11, 1915; 172 App. Div. 913, Jan. 5, 1916.

265

Butler v. Sheffield Farms, S. D. R., vol. 6, p. 368, Dec. 14, 1915..
Caccavano v. N. Y., Ontario & Western R. R. Co., S. D. R., vol. 6, p. 380, Dec.

115

16, 1915; 174 App. Div. 900, June 30, 1916..

265

Cahill v. Terry & Tench Co., 173 App. Div. 418, June, 1916.
Cantor v. Rubin Musicant Co., S. D. R., vol. 3, p. 392, Apr. 22, 1915.
Cappelli v. Cranford, S. D. R., vol. 6, p. 349, Nov. 24, 1915..
Carbone v. Loft, 174 App. Div. 901, June 30, 1916; 219 N. Y.

*122, 314

*260

255

Oct. 24, 1916. 217

PAGE

Carini v. Nickel Plate R. R., S. D. R., vol. 4, p. 423, June 25, 1915.........197, 265 Carkey v. Island Paper Co., S. D. R., vol. 6, p. 321, Nov. 3, 1915; App. Div. .276, 283, 331 Carroll v. Knickerbocker Ice Co., 169 App. Div. 450, Sept. 15, 1915; 218 N. Y. 435, July 11, 1916. . . . .116, 250, *367, *369,*380 Chappelle v. Four Hundred and Twelve Broadway Co., 171 App. Div. 958, Nov. 22, 1915; 218 N. Y. Rep. 632, 736, Apr. 25 and June 16, 1916. Cino v. Morton & Gorman Contracting Co., S. D. R., vol. 5, p. 387, Aug. 3, 1915; 172 App. Div. 917, Jan. 18, 1916..

109

..198, 266

Collins v. Brooklyn Union Gas Co., S. D. R., vol. 4, p. 449, July 13, 1915; 171 App. Div. 381, Jan. 18, 1916... . . .

*100, 376 *301

Connors v. Semet-Solvay Co., 94 Misc. 405, Mar., 1916.
Cook v. N. Y. Central & H. R. R. R. Co., S. D. R., vol. 8, p. 469, Apr. 27, 1916 255
Costello v. Taylor, 169 App. Div. 905, May, 1915; 217 N. Y. 179, Feb. 1, 1916. .57, *183
Countryman v. Neuman, S. D. R., vol. 7, p. 421, Feb. 4, 1916; 174 App. Div.
900, June 30, 1916...

.196, 266

Cowen v. Cowen's New Shirt Laundry, S. D. R., vol. 8, p. 481, May 3, 1916; App. Div. —, Dec. 29, 1916....

Cremin v. Mordecai & Son, 171 App. Div. 958, Nov., 1915. .

Crockett v. International Railway Co., 170 App. Div. 122, Nov. 10, 1915;
App. Div., Dec. 29, 1916....

*99

109

.307, *398

Cunningham v. Buffalo C. & B. Rolling Mills, 171 App. Div. 955, Nov., 1915

*282, 339, 395

314

Dale v. Saunders Bros., S. D. R., vol. 5, p. 372, July 16, 1915; 171 App. Div.
528, Mar. 15, 1916; 218 N. Y. 59, Apr. 25, 1916.... ..266, *341, *346, 400
D'Angelo v. Smith & Co. & Locher, Files of the Commission, No. 60063..
Dearborn v. Peugeot Auto Import Co., 170 App. Div. 93, Nov. 10, 1915; S. D.
R., vol. 7, p. 413, Feb. 3, 1916;
Nov. 15, 1916.. *233, 266,

- App. Div.

309, 333

De Filippis v. Falkenberg, S. D. R., vol. 4, p. 375, Apr. 30, 1915; 170 App. Div.
153, Nov. 10, 1915; 219 N. Y. Rep., Oct. 24, 1916....
DeLaGardelle v. Hampton Co., 167 App. Div. 617; May 5, 1915.
DeVoe v. N. Y. State Railways, 169 App. Div. 472, Sept. 15, 1915; 218 N. Y.
318, June 6, 1916...

*95, 197

.*102, 262

*75, *79

Dunn v. West End Brewing Co., S. D. R., vol. 5, p. 380, July 26, 1915; 174 App.
Div. 900, June 30, 1916...

Dunham v. Phelan & Sullivan, Monthly Bulletin of Dept. of Labor, June, 1916, p. 30......

Diciaiulo v. Kerbaugh, S. D. R., vol. 1, p. 424, Nov. 5, 1914.
Dick v. Knoperbaum, 157 N. Y. Supp. 754, Mar. 13, 1916..
DiPaolo v. Crimmins Contracting Co., S. D. R., vol. 5, p. 428, Nov. 3, 1915;
173 App. Div. 988, May 3, 1916; 219 N. Y. Rep., Oct. 24, 1916...... *196, 266
Dolici v. Myers Contracting Co., S. D. R., vol. 4, p. 376, May 4, 1915; 172 App.
Div. 914, Jan., 1916.....

197

*113

265

272

.115, 253

.*262

50

Edwardsen v. Jarvis Lighterage Co., 168 App. Div. 368, May 7, 1915.
Eldridge v. Endicott Johnson & Co., S. D. R., vol. 8, p. 445, Apr. 12, 1916.....
Fagan v. U. T. Co., Files of Commission, Claim No. 36456, Feb. 23, 1916..... 333
Fairchild v. Pa. R. R. Co., 170 App. Div. 135, Nov. 10, 1915... *179, 333, 400
Farrar v. Gristede Bros., Files of Commission, Claim No. 24089, Jan. 19, 1916.. 266

Feinman v. Albert Manufacturing Co., S. D. R., vol. 4, p. 365, April 26, 1915;
170 App. Div. 147, November 10, 1915..
Fiocca v. Dillon, S. D. R., vol. 7, p. 399, Feb. 1, 1916;
15, 1916.......

PAGE

*293

App. Div.

Nov.

.235, 264 *396

Fitzsimmons v. Wadsworth, S. D. R., vol. 6, p. 351, Nov. 24, 1915..
Foley v. Bretton Hall Co., S. D. R., vol. 4, p. 339, Mar. 26, 1915; 172 App. Div.
914, Jan., 1916.....

197

Fortino v. Merchants' Despatch Transportation Co., S. D. R., vol. 3, p. 369,
Feb. 13, 1915; 171 App. Div. 956, Nov., 1915....
Fredenberg v. Empire U. Railways, 168 App. Div. 618, July 1, 1915; 170 App.
Div. 942, Sept. 14, 1915.....

*296

*277, *331, 333

*309, 312

Friscia v. Drake Bros. Co., 167 App. Div. 496, May 5, 1915... Gardner v. Horseheads Construction Co., S. D. R., vol. 4, p. 437, June 30, 1915; 171 App. Div. 66, Jan. 5, 1916.....

.*154,*374

Gallien v. N. Y. Central & H. R. R. R. Co., 172 App. Div. 918, Jan., 1916..... 174
Gibbons v. Tager Contracting Co., S. D. R., vol. 5, p. 434, Nov. 13, 1915; 174
App. Div. 900, June 30, 1916...

*359

Gimber v. Kane Co., S. D. R., vol. 2, p. 475, Nov., 1914; 171 App. Div. 958, Nov., 1915....

.340, 341

Glatzl v. Stumpp, S. D. R., vol. 6, p. 397, Dec. 29, 1915; 174 App. Div. 901,
June 30, 1916; N. Y. Jan. 30, 1917..
Gleisner v. Gross & Herbener, 170 App. Div. 37, Nov. 10, 1915...
Glidder v. Haliver, S. D. R., vol. 6, p. 366, Dec. 14, 1915....
Goldstein v. Centre Iron Works, 167 App. Div. 526, May 5, 1915.
Grady v. Holliday, 171 App. Div. 959, Nov., 1915.

Graf v. Brooklyn R. T. Co., S. D. R., vol. 7, p. 381, Jan. 18, 1916.
Grammici v. Zinn, S. D. R., vol. 5, p. 400, Aug. 18, 1915; 173 App. Div. 922,
March 8, 1916; 219 N. Y. 322, Nov. 28. 1916..

Gray v. DeJong, S. D. R., vol. 5, p. 404, Aug. 26, 1915; 173 App. Div. 922, Mar., 1916.

Griffiths v. A. B. Enamel Co., S. D. R., vol. 8, p. 429, April 4, 1916.
Gutheil v. Consolidated Gas Co., 94 Misc. 690, April, 1916.....

*192

*89, 185

.*397

*366

104

388

.283, *284

197

248

*109

Hall v. Lehigh Valley R. R. Co., S. D. R., vol. 4, p. 441, July 1, 1915; 171 App. Div. 961, Nov., 1915..

174

Harnett v. Steen Co., S. D. R., vol. 2, p. 492, Jan. 20, 1915; 169 App. Div. 905, May, 1915; 216 N. Y. 101, Oct., 19, 1915.....

*213, 401

Harrison v. Kane, 169 App. Div. 905, May 28, 1915.... Heitz v. Ruppert Brewery Co., 171 App. Div. 961, Nov., 1915; 218 N. Y. 148, 702, May 2 and June 30, 1916.....

221

*214

Henry v. Levor & Co., S. D. R., vol. 6, p. 388, Dec. 20, 1915...
Herkey v. Agar Manufacturing Co., 90 Misc. 457, May, 1915. . . . . . *32, 50, 126, 221
Hill v. N. Y. Consolidated R. R. Co. 174 App. Div. 900, June 30, 1916.....196, 265
Hirsch v. Zurich General A. & L. Ins. Co., 97 Misc. 360, Nov., 1916..
Hotaling v. Standard Oil Co. of N. Y., S. D. R., vol. 6, p 308, Sept. 30, 1915... 82
Hyland v. Winant, S. D. R., vol. 6, p. 304, Sept. 23, 1915...
Ignatowsky v. Berman, S. D. R., vol. 6, p. 326, Nov. 15, 1915.
Itzikowitz v. Lakner, S. D. R., vol. 5, p. 398, Aug. 12, 1915...
James v. Witherbee-Sherman & Co., S. D. R., vol. 2, p. 483, Jan. 9, 1915... *206, 265

Hendricks v. Seeman Bros., S. D. R., vol. 3, p. 385, Mar. 30, 1915; 170 App. Div. 133, Nov. 15, 1915..

*190, 314, 400

.255, 266

272

.255, *396

115

331

PAGE

Jennings v. Dept. of Public Works of N. Y., S. D. R., vol. 5, p. 416, Sept. 29, 1915.

127

.283, *285 *267

98

Jensen v. Southern Pacific Co., 167 App. Div. 945, Mar., 1915; 215 N. Y. 514, July 13, 1915.. .21, *22, 50, 159, 174 Kanzar v. Acorn Manufacturing Co., S. D. R., vol. 5, p. 418, Oct. 1, 1915; 173 App. Div. 988, May 3, 1916; 219 N. Y. 326, Nov. 28, 1916.. Keigher v. General Electric Co., 173 App. Div. 207, May 3, 1916. Kelleher v. Swift & Co., S. D. R., vol. 4, p. 356, April 20, 1915.. Kennedy v. Kennedy Manufacturing and Engineering Co., S. D. R., vol. 7, p. 383; Monthly Bulletin of Dept. of Labor, May, 1916, p. 8, April 27, 1916. *260 Kenny v. Union Railway Co., 166 App. Div. 497, Mar. 3, 1915........ *256, 365, 400 Kiernan v. Friestedt Underpinning Co., S. D. R., vol. 5, p. 390, Aug. 5, 1915; 171 App. Div. 539, Mar. 8, 1916... .115, *195, 266 Kiernan v. Schermerhorn Estate, S. D. R., vol. 8, p. 483, May 3, 1916......195, 264 Kilberg v. Vitch, S. D. R., vol. 4, p. 434, June 30, 1915; 171 App. Div. 89, Jan. 5, 1916...

*330

Kingsley v. Donovan, S. D. R., vol. 3, p. 367, Feb. 13, 1915; 169 App. Div. 828, Nov. 10, 1915....

*217

Kohler v. Frohmann, 167 App. Div. 533, May 5, 1915..

*394

Kolb v. Borden's Condensed Milk Co., S. D. R., vol. 4, p. 347, April 6, 1915; 173 App. Div. 988, May 3, 1916.

311

Krenzien v. Jasper, S. D. R., vol. 7, p. 373, Jan. 13, 1916..

256

Kreppel v. Boyland, S. D. R., vol. 2, p. 489, Jan. 9, 1915.

*276

.340, 341

Landrigan v. Cochran, S. D. R., vol. 6, p. 310, Oct. 4, 1915.
Larsen v. Paine Drug Co., 169 App. Div. 838, Nov. 10, 1915; 218 N. Y. 252,
May 12, 1916...

*187, *188, 264, 395

Lazarick v. N. Y., N. H. & H. R. R. Co., 171 App. Div. 959, Nov., 1915....196, 266 Lehmann v. Ramo Films, 92 Misc. 418, Nov., 1915. ...

Leslie v. O'Connor & Richman, S. D. R., vol. 5, p. 383, July 28, 1915; 173 App. Div. 988, May 3, 1916.......

*158

.184, 197

Lester v. Otis Elevator Co., 90 Misc. 649, June, 1915; 169 App. Div. 613, Nov. 5, 1915.....

.116, *222, *228

Lindebauer v. Weiner, 94 Misc. 612, Mar., 1916....

*111

Lloyd v. Power Specialty Co., S. D. R., vol. 7, p. 409, Feb. 3, 1916.
Ludwig v. Groh's Sons, S. D. R., vol. 8, p. 426, April 1, 1916..

*157

*114

Lyon v. Windsor & Davis, S. D. R., vol. 5, p. 389, Aug. 5, 1915; 173 App. Div. 377, May 18, 1916...

*145, 380

McCabe v. Brooklyn Heights R. R. Co., S. D. R., vol. 8, p. 407, Mar. 15, 1916; App. Div.-, Jan. 9, 1917..

79

McCaffrey v. Tager Contracting Co., S. D. R., vol. 5, p. 434, Nov. 13, 1915; App. Div. -, June 30, 1916.

*359

McIntire v. Hilliard Hotel Co., 171 App. Div. 958, Nov. 22, 1915; 218 N. Y.
Rep. 642, 736, May 2 and June 16, 1916..

109

McMahon v. Interborough R. T. Co., S. D. R., vol. 5, pp. 371, 374, July 16, 1915

254, 265

McManus v. R. H. Macy & Co., S. D. R., vol. 6, p. 344, Nov. 24, 1915.
McMurray v. Little & Ives Co., S. D. R., vol. 3, p. 395, April 27, 1915..
McNeill v. Hogan & Sons, S. D. R., vol. 7, p. 469, Mar. 7, 1916. .
McQueeney v. Sutphen & Myer, 167 App. Div. 528, May 5, 1915.

*92

254

307

.30, *392

Mandel v. Steinhardt & Bros., S. D. R., vol. 6, p. 390, Dec. 21, 1915; 173 App. Div. 515, June 30, 1916..

PAGE

*145

Marhoffer v. Marhoffer, S. D. R., vol. 8, p. 438, April 6, 1916; 175 App. Div. 52, Nov. 15, 1916.

280

Marinaccio v. Flinn-O'Rourke Co., S. D. R., vol. 6, p. 318, Nov. 3, 1915; 172 App. Div. 378, May 3, 1916.....

*389

Markell v. Green Felt Shoe Co., S. D. R., vol. 8, p. 487, May 4, 1916;

App.

Div.

Nov. 15, 1916..

98

Martin v. Roff Underwear Co., S. D. R., vol. 7, p. 481, Mar. 8, 1916;-
Div., Dec. 29, 1916...

App.

286

*220

..57, *287, *290, 297,*405

Martucci v. Hills Bros. Co., 171 App. Div. 370, Jan. 18, 1916. Matter of Petrie, 165 App. Div. 561, Jan. 6, 1915; 215 N. Y. 335, June 15, 1915; 218 N. Y. Rep. 730, June 16, 1916... Mazzarisi v. Ward & Tully, S. D. R., vol. 4, p. 443, July 8, 1915; 170 App. Div. 868, Jan. 5, 1916....

Meyer v. Morris & Co., S. D. R., vol. 6, p. 334, Nov. 24, 1915; 173 App. Div. 990, May 18, 1916; - N. Y. —, Dec. 12, 1916.. Mihm v. Hussey, 169 App. Div. 742, Nov. 10, 1915..

Mike v. Glens Falls Portland Cement Co., S. D. R., vol. 7, p. 435, Feb. 10, 1916. *306
Miller v. N. Y. Railways Co., 171 App. Div. 316, Jan. 21, 1916....... .*52, 111, 126
Miller v. Taylor, S. D. R., vol. 7, p. 396, Jan. 26, 1916; 173 App. Div. 865, June
30, 1916....

.*191

Miner v. Turnbull, S. D. R., vol. 7, p. 474, Mar. 7, 1916...

.*358

Minnaugh v. Brooklyn Union Gas Co., S. D. R., vol. 8, p. 466, April 27, 1916... 115
Mockler v. Hawkes, 173 App. Div. 333, May 3, 1916..
Mohr v. Cranford, S. D. R., vol. 7, p. 376, Jan. 16, 1916....

*291

255

Mooney v. Weber Piano Co., S. D. R., vol. 5, p. 396, Aug. 11, 1915; 172 App. Div. 917, Jan. 18, 1916..

.195, 256, 265

Moore v. Lehigh Valley R. R. Co., S. D. R., vol. 2, p. 472, Oct. 30, 1914; 169
App. Div. 177, July 1, 1915; 217 N. Y. Rep. 627, Jan. 25, 1916. .57, 173, *199, 265
Morey v. Worden, S. D. R., vol. 2, p. 494, Jan. 28, 1915..

Morrissey v. N. Y. Rys. Co., 170 App. Div. 926, July, 1915..

307

Myers v. Smith, Files of Commission, Claim No. 6222, March 29, 1915..
Naud v. King Sewing Machine Co., 95 Misc. 676, June 20, 1916..
Neuner v. Hanschman, S. D. R., vol. 8, p. 500, Mar. 25, 1916...

99

*402

.*306

New Amsterdam Casualty Co. v. Olcott, 165 App. Div. 603, Dec. 31, 1914...... *37 Newman v. Newman, 169 App. Div. 745, Nov. 10, 1915; 218 N. Y. 325, June 6, 1916....

*83, *86

Nicholson v. Klipstein & Co., S. D. R., vol. 4, p. 412, June 8, 1915; 171 App.
Div. 970, Dec. 3, 1915....

.153, 197

Nolan v. Cranford Co., S. D. R., vol. 4, p. 337, Mar. 23, 1915; 171 App. Div. 959, Nov., 1915; 219 N. Y. Rep., Oct. 24, 1916.

340

Noonan v. Yellow Taxicab Service, Files of Commission, Claim No. 14485,
Mar. 3, 1916....

334

Norman v. Empire Lighterage & Wrecking Co., S. D. R., vol. 2, p. 480, Jan. 9, 1915.

340

Oberg v. McRoberts & Co., S. D. R., vol. 6, p. 386, Dec. 20, 1915; 175 App. Div. 1, Nov. 15, 1916. . . . . .

.264, 340

Okrzesz v. Lehigh Valley R. R. Co., S. D. R., vol. 3, p. 371, Feb. 13, 1915; 170 App. Div. 15, Nov. 10, 1915..

.*178