Opinion of the Court. estimate seems to have been accepted by the parties as correct. He estimated that the percentage of operating expenses on local business would exceed the percentage of operating expenses on all business by at least ten per cent, and that it might go as high as twenty per cent or higher. And this view is more than sustained by the evidence of witnesses possessing special knowledge of railroad transportation and of the cost of doing local business as compared with what is called through business. Indeed, one of those witnesses states that the cost of carrying local freight is four times as much as the cost of through freight per ton per mile; another, that the cost of the short haul is "reasonably double the long haul." If due regard be had to the testimony - and we have no other basis for our judgment we are not permitted to place the extra cost of local business at less than ten per cent greater than the percentage of the cost of all business. In answer to questions propounded to him by the defendants constituting the State Board of Transportation, Mr. Dilworth stated that he had prepared himself with an esti mate showing the number of tons of freight, commonly spoken of as local freight, hauled on the respective railways in Nebraska, and the amount received by the railway companies by way of tariff on tons of freight hauled, including through as well as local freight, and was qualified to speak as to the amount received by the companies for both passengers and freight within the State, and the reduction that would take place in rates under the statute in question. He presented various tables showing the results of his investigations. One is known as Exhibit 4, and is an "Estimate of local business, and the effect of House Roll 33" on the Burlington, St. Paul, Fremont, Union Pacific, Omaha, St. Joseph and Kansas City Companies for the year 1892. Another is called Exhibit 19, and is a like estimate in respect of the same companies for the years 1891 and 1893. Another is known as Exhibit 20, and shows "Tons carried, tonnage per mile and percentage of expenses for the years ending June 30, 1891, 1892 and 1893 (Nebraska)." These exhibits are as follows: VOL. CLXIX-34 Exhibit "4." Estimate of Local Business and the Effect of House Roll 33 on the Following-named Railroads: Exhibit "19." Estimate of Local Business and the Effect of House Roll 33 on the Following-named Railroads for the Years ending June 30, 1891 and 1893. Exhibit "20." Tons carried, Tonnage per Mile and Percentage of Expenses for Years ending June 30, 1891, 1892 and 1893 NAME OF ROAD. Number of tons carried locally. Number of tons of inter state freight carried. (Nebraska). 73,075,310 106,415,962 269,491,272 69,594,747 66.24 St. Paul Co. 64,496 228,671 10,267,118 36,397,629 46,664,747 , 7,403,263 70.78 Fremont Co. 141,056 654,400 21,863,680 101,644,999 123,508,679 24,898,729 49.87 Union Pacific Co. 152,028 1,908,045 28,908,124 362,966,694 391,874,818 66,072,597 68.94 Omaha Co. 61,448 409,270 4,579,104 30,499,041 35,078,145 10,295,137 120.20 St. Joseph Co. 25,078 178,169 1,497,058 10,640,979 12,138,637 2,308,918 96.44 Kansas City Co. 8,743 78,694 403,751 3,634,082 4,037,833 912,210 99.54 Opinion of the Court. It may be here stated that the words in these exhibits, "number of tons hauled locally," refer to freight that started and ended in the State; the words in Exhibit 4, "amount received for freight hauled in Nebraska, including through and local," and the like words in Exhibit 19, refer not only to freight starting and ending in the State, but to all freight hauled by the railroad company in Nebraska, regardless of its destination or origin- that is, "freight that begins in the State and goes out of the State, freight that begins out of the State and comes into the State and freight which begins and ends in the State." The words, "per cent of reduction on all the business done in the State by House Roll 33," in Exhibits 4 and 19, mean the percentage of the total amount of all business, passenger and freight, done in the State, whatever its origin or destination, and do not indicate the percentage of reduction on local business when considered, alone. It should be stated also that the words, "percentage of expenses to earnings," in Exhibit 20, refer to all business, through and local, done by the railroad company within the State. Mr. Dilworth, as we have seen, testified that if the local business alone were considered, the percentage of expenses to earnings upon such business would be at least ten per cent more than the general percentage of expenses to earnings on all business, both through and local. It is important here to note that his estimates are of business from July 1st to the succeeding June 30th. So that when allusion is made presently to his estimates for 1891, 1892 and 1893, it will be understood to refer to the years ending the 30th days of June, 1891, 1892 and 1893, respectively. From July 1, 1890, to June 30, 1891, as shown by Exhibit 20, the percentage of expenses to earnings on all business on the Burlington road was 66.24; on the St. Paul road, 70.78; on the Fremont road, 49.87; on the Union Pacific road, 68.94; on the Omaha road, 120.26; on the St. Joseph road, 96.44; and on the Kansas City road, 99.54; From July 1, 1891, to June 30, 1892, as shown by the same Exhibit, the percentage of expenses to earnings on all business on the Burlington road was 64.23; on the St. Paul |