Equity and the Constitution: The Supreme Court, Equitable Relief, and Public Policy
University of Chicago Press, 1982 - 179 páginas
Since the landmark desegregation decisions in the Brown vs. Board of Education cases, the proper role of the federal judiciary has been hotly debated. Has the federal judiciary, in its attempt to legislate social policy, overstepped its constitutional boundaries?
In this volume, Gary McDowell considers the equity power created by Article III of the Constitution, on which the most controversial decisions of the Supreme Court have rested. He points out the equity was originally understood as an extraordinary means of offering relief to individuals in cases of fraud, accident, mistake, or trust and as a means of "confining the operation of unjust and partial laws." It has now been stretched to offer relief to broadly defined social classes. This "sociological" understanding, in McDowell's view, has undermined equity as a substantive body of law. He urges a return to the former definition as a means of restraining the reach of federal jurisdiction.
Comentarios de la gente - Escribir un comentario
No encontramos ningún comentario en los lugares habituales.
administration American Equity American Law Aristotle authority Board of Education Brown Brown II Chief Justice Civil Procedure Codification Movement Commentaries on Equity common law Congress Constitution County Court of Chancery courts of equity courts of law David Dudley Field decrees denied desegregation doctrine DuPonceau equal protection equitable relief equitable remedial equity jurisdiction equity jurisprudence Equity Pleadings equity power equity procedures exercise federal courts Federal Farmer federal judiciary Federalist Fourteenth Amendment fundamental Graglia Hamilton Hecht Hobbes Ibid Idea of Equity James Madison Joseph Story judges judgment judicial discretion judicial power law and equity Legibus legislative legislature Misc natural law necessary opinion particular Philadelphia Convention political positive law power of equity precedent principles of equity question racial reason Republic republican Rutgers segregation separate statute Story's substantive Supreme Court Swann Thomas Jefferson tion tradition of equity understanding of equity United Warren York