Mr. John A. Gilmer Daniel W. Gooch Mr. Robert Mallory Gilman Marston Mr. William N. H. Smith Elbridge G. Spaulding So the House refused to lay the resolution on the table. The question then recurring on the said resolution, Mr. Cobb moved to amend the same by inserting after the word “that the words, “the gentleman from Massachusetts, Mr. Train, and." Pending which, and during the debate thereon, Mr. Dawes was called to order by Mr. Jackson for words spoken by him, whereby he had insinuated, as alleged by Mr. Jackson, that the gentleman from Alabama (Mr. Cobb) was not a gentleman. The speaker decided that, inasmuch as the words spoken did not, in his opinion, admit of the construction given them by Mr. Jackson, the member from Massachusetts, Mr. Dawes was in order. No appeal having been taken from this decision of the Chair, Mr. Dawes proceeded with his remarks. After further debate, Yeas ...................... 70 It was decided in the negative, 3 wie, | Nays ......................100 The yeas and nays being desired by one-fifth of the members present, Those who voted in the affirmative are Mr. William T. Avery William Barksdale Mr David Clopton John Cochrane Mr. Muscoe R. H. Garnett Lucius J. Gartrell Mr George W. Hughes James Jackson Mr. Sydenham Moore William E. Niblack Mr. William Smith James A. Stallworth Those who voted in the negative areMr. Charles F. Adams Mr. Orris S. Ferry Mr. Thomas A. R. Nelson John J. Perry John U. Pettit Albert G. Porter John F. Potter Emory B. Pottle John H. Reynolds Alexander H. Rice Christopher Robinson Homer E. Royce John Sherman William N. H. Smith Francis E. Spinner Benjamin Stanton Thaddeus Stevens William Stewart William B. Stokes John L. N. Stratton Mason W. Tappan Eli Thayer Thomas C. Theaker Henry C. Longnecker Cydnor B. Tompkins Carey A Trimble William Vandever Charles H. Van Wyck John P. Verree Henry Waldron E. P. Walton Ellihu B. Washburne Israel Washburn, jr. Alfred Wells William Windom John Woodruff. 1 Yeas................ 91 And it was decided in the affirmative, s | Nays... ............ 78 The yeas and nays being desired by one-fifth of the members present, Those who voted in the affirmative are Mr. Charles F. Adams Garnett B Adrain Mr. John A. Bingham Harrison G. Blake Mr. Martin Butterfield James H. Campbell Mr. Charles Delano R. Holland Duell Mr. Benjamin F. Junkin Williain S Kenyon Mr. Homer E. Royce John Sherman Those who voted in the negative are Mr. Green Adams William Allen Mr. Lucius J. Gartrell Andrew J. Hamilton Mr. William Montgomery Sydenham Moore So it was ordered that the main question be now put. The Speaker having stated the question to be first on the amendment submitted by Mr. Cobb to the resolution submitted by Mr. Sherman Mr. Crawford made the point of order that the propositions to censure the said members (Messrs. Train and Houston) fell by reason of other business having intervened. The Speaker overruled the said point of order. On motion of Mr. Israel Washburn, jr., Ordered, That the said appeal be laid on the table. Mr. Winslow moved that the whole subject be laid on the table. And the question being put, 5 Yeas................... 70 It was decided in the negative, } von Nays................... 99 The yeas and nays being desired by one-fifth of the members present, Those who voted in the affirmative are Mr. William T. Avery William Barksdale Mr Muscoe R. H. Garnett Lucius J. Gartrell Mr. Sydenham Moore William E. Niblack Those who voted in the negative areMr. Charles F. Adams Mr. Reuben E. Fenton Green Adams Orris S. Ferry Garnett B. Adrain Stephen C. Foster Cyrus Aldrich Augustus Frank William Allen Ezra B. French John B. Alley John A. Gilmer William C. Anderson Daniel W. Gooch James M. Ashley James H. Graham Elijah Babbitt Galusha A. Grow Charles L. Beale John A. Gurley John A. Bingham James T. Hale Harrison G. Blake William Helmick William D. Brayton John Hickman Francis M. Bristow Charles B. Hoar i James Buffinton William A. Howard Anson Burlingame James Humphrey Alfred A. Burnham William Irvine Martin Butterfield William Kellogg James H. Campbell William S. Kenyon John Carey David Kilgore Luther C. Carter John W. Killinger Williamson R. W. Cobb DeWitt C. Leach Schayler Colfax James M. Leach Thomas Corwin M. Lindley Loe John Covode Henry C. Longpecker Henry L. Dawes Dwight Loomis Charles Delano Owen Lovejoy R. Holland Duell Robert Mallory Sidney Edgerton Gilman Marston Thomas D. Eliot James B. McKean Mr. Robert McKnight Edward McPherson Mr. John P. Verree Henry Waldron Mr. Ellihu B. Washburne Israel Washburn, jr. Mr. William Windom John Woodruff. So the House refused to lay the subject on the table. Mr. Lamar moved, at 3 o'clock and 20 minutes p. m., that the House adjourn. And the question being put, (Yeas................... 60 It was decided in the negative, 3 un ) Nays.................. 97 The yeas and nays being desired by one-fifth of the members present, Those who voted in the affirmative are Mr. William T. Avery William Barksdale Mr. Thomas B. Florence Muscoe R. H. Garnett Mr. William E. Niblack John S. Phelps Those who voted in the negative are Mr. Charles F. Adams Green Adams Mr. Orris S. Ferry Stephen C. Foster Mr Gilman Marston Horace Maynard |