Imágenes de páginas
PDF
EPUB

CONTENTS

[ocr errors][ocr errors]
[ocr errors]

50

--

-

-

-

[ocr errors]

Power of the Judiciary over legislation the supreme issue - Federal-
ist majorities in State Legislatures assert that Supreme Court can
annul acts of Congress Republican minorities vigorously resist the
doctrine of Judiciary supremacy - Republican strength grows rap-
idly Critical situation before the decision of Marbury vs. Madi-
son- - Power of the Supreme Court must be promptly asserted or
permanently abandoned Marshall confronts a serious dilemma
Escape from it apparently impossible - Republicans expect/him
to decide against Madison They threaten impeachment Mar-
shall delivers his celebrated opinion His reasoning on the power
of the Judiciary merely repeats Federalist arguments in the Judiciary
debate He persuades his associates on the Supreme Bench that
Section 13 of the Ellsworth Judiciary Act is unconstitutional -
Startling boldness of his conception - History of Section 13-
Drawn by framers of the Constitution and never before questioned
- Marshall's opinion excites no immediate comment - Jefferson

does not attack it until after his reëlection - Republican opposition

to the Judiciary apparently subsides Cause of this - Purchase of

Louisiana-Jefferson compelled to take "unconstitutional" action

- He counsels secrecy · The New England Federalist secession

movement gains strength-Jefferson reëlected - Impeachment

the next move.

-

[ocr errors]
[ocr errors]

-

-

Republicans plan to subjugate the Judiciary - Federalist Judges
to be ousted and Republicans put in their places · Marshall's deci-
sion in United States vs. Fisher-The Republican impeachment pro-
gramme carried out - The trial and the conviction of Judge Addi-
son-The removal of Judge Pickering - The House impeaches
Justice Chase of the Supreme Court Republicans manipulate
public opinion-The articles of impeachment Federalists con-
vinced that Chase is doomed-Marshall the chief object of attack –
His alarm - He proposes radical method of reviewing decisions of
the Supreme Court - Reason for Marshall's trepidation - The im-
peachment trial Burr presides - He is showered with favors by
the Administration - Appearance of Chase - His brilliant array
of counsel-Luther Martin of Maryland - Examination of wit-
- Marshall testifies He makes an unfavorable impression:

"too much caution; too much fear; too much cunning" - Argu-

[ocr errors]
[ocr errors][merged small]

-

ments of counsel - Weakness of the House managers - They are
overwhelmed by counsel for Chase - Joseph Hopkinson's brilliant
appeal - He captivates the Senate-Nicholson's fatal admission
Rodney's absurd speech-Luther Martin's great argument — Ran-
dolph closes for the managers — He apostrophizes Marshall — Hi
pathetic breakdown - The Senate votes - Tense excitement in the
Chamber- Chase acquitted — A determinative event in American
history - Independence of the National Judiciary saved
shall for the first time secure in the office of Chief Justice.

-

-

-

Mar-

[ocr errors]
[ocr errors]

The people receive him cordially - He is given remarkable ovation
at Nashville - Andrew Jackson's ardent friendship —- Burr enthu-
siastically welcomed at New Orleans - War with Spain seemingly
inevitable-Burr plans to lead attack upon Mexico when hostili-
ties begin Spanish agents start rumors against him — Eastern
papers print sensational stories - Burr returns to the Capital -
Universal demand for war with Spain - Burr intrigues in Wash-
ington - He again starts for the West-He sends his famous
cipher dispatch to Wilkinson - Blennerhassett joins Burr - They
purchase four hundred thousand acres of land on the Washita River
Plan to settle this land if war not declared - Wilkinson's eager-
ness for war - Burr arraigned in the Kentucky courts - He is dis-
charged - Cheered by the people Wilkinson determines to
betray Burr-He writes mysterious letters to the President
Jefferson issues his Proclamation - Wilkinson's reign of military
lawlessness in New Orleans Arrest of Burr's agents, Bollmann
and Swartwout — Arrest of Adair - Prisoners sent under guard by
ship to Washington - The capital filled with wild rumors - Jef-
ferson's slight mention of the Burr conspiracy in his Annual Mes-
sage Congress demands explanation — Jefferson sends Special
Message denouncing Burr: his“ guilt is placed beyond question"
Effect upon the public mind-Burr already convicted in popu-
lar opinion.

-

-

-

VII. THE CAPTURE AND ARRAIGNMENT

[ocr errors]

-

-

Bollmann and Swartwout arrive at Washington and are impris-
oned - Adair and Alexander released by the court at Baltimore
for want of proof - Eaton's affidavit against Burr - Bollmann and
Swartwout apply to Supreme Court for writ of habeas corpus-
Senate passes bill suspending the privilege of that writ — The
House indignantly rejects the Senate Bill - Marshall delivers the
first of!
of his series of opinions on treason No evidence against Boll-
mann and Swartwout, and Marshall discharges them Violent
debate in the House - Burr, ignorant of all, starts down the
Cumberland and Mississippi with nine boats and a hundred men
-First learns in Mississippi of the proceedings against him
Voluntarily surrenders to the civil authorities - The Mississippi
grand jury refuses to indict Burr, asserting that he is guilty of no
offense Court refuses to discharge him- Wilkinson's frantic
efforts to seize or kill him He goes into hiding-Court forfeits
his bond - He escapes He is captured in Alabama and confined
to Fort Stoddert-Becomes popular with both officers and men —
Taken under military guard for a thousand miles through the wil-
derness - Arrives at Richmond - Marshall issues warrant for his
delivery to the civil authorities - The first hearing before the
Chief Justice-Shall Burr be committed for treason
-The argu-
ment - Marshall's opinion-Probable cause to suspect Burr
guilty of attempt to attack Mexico; no evidence upon which to
commit Burr for treason - Marshall indirectly criticizes Jefferson
- Burr's letters to his daughter Popular demand for Burr's con-

-

-

-

---

343

viction and execution - Jefferson writes bitterly of Marshall —
Administration scours country for evidence against Burr — Ex-
penditure of public money for this purpose - Burr gains friends
in Richmond-His attorneys become devoted to him-Mar-
shall attends the famous dinner at the house of John Wickham,
not knowing that Burr is to be a guest - He is denounced for
doing so - - His state of mind.

-

VIII. ADMINISTRATION VERSUS COURT

-

Richmond thronged with visitors-Court opens in the House of
Delegates - The hall packed - Dress, appearance, and manner
of spectators - Dangerous state of the public temper - Andrew
Jackson arrives and publicly denounces Jefferson-He declares
trial a "political persecution"-Winfield Scott's opinion: the
President the real prosecutor - Grand jury formed and instructed
- Believe Burr guilty - Burr's passionate reply to George Hay,
the District Attorney - Hay reports to Jefferson - Burr's counsel
denounce the Administration's efforts to excite the public against
him — Attorneys on both sides speak to the public — Hay moves
to commit Burr for treason - Marshall's difficult and dangerous
situation - Jefferson instructs Hay-Government offers testi-
mony to support its motion-Luther Martin arrives — Hay
again reports to Jefferson, who showers the District Attorney with
orders - Burr asks that the court grant a writ of subpoena duces
tecum directed to Jefferson - Martin boldly attacks the President
- Wirt's clever rejoinder — Jefferson calls Martin that "Federal
bulldog"-Wants Martin indicted-Marshall's opinion on Burr's
motion for a subpœna duces tecum — He grants the writ - Hay
writes Jefferson, who makes able and dignified reply - Wilkinson
arrives-Washington Irving's description of him - Testimony be-
fore the grand jury - Burr and Blennerhassett indicted for treason
and misdemeanor - Violent altercations between counsel.

[merged small][ocr errors]

-

-

-

-

-

Burr becomes popular with Richmond society Swartwout chal-
lenges Wilkinson to a duel - Marshall sets the trial for August 3
The prisoner's life in the penitentiary · Burr's letters to his daugh-
ter - Marshall asks his associates on the Supreme Bench for their
opinions - Trial begins — Difficulty of selecting a jury — Every-
body convinced of Burr's guilt - Hay writes Jefferson that Marshall
favors Burr-At last jury is formed - The testimony - No overt
act proven - Burr's counsel move that collateral testimony shall
not be received - Counsel on both sides make powerful and bril-
liant arguments- Marshall delivers his famous opinion on the law
of constructive treason - Jury returns verdict of not guilty - Jef-
ferson declares Marshall is trying to keep evidence from the public
He directs Hay to press trial on indictment for misdemeanor
Burr demands letters called for in the subpoena duces tecum to Jef-
ferson-President attempts to arrange a truce with the Chief Jus-

-

398

[ocr errors][merged small]
« AnteriorContinuar »